The Inexplicable Success of Manager Jake Taylor in Major League II

Thanks to a fever, I’ve had a day and a half to nap and watch crappy television. Enter Major League II, which I had last seen on a bus in college en route to a game in suburban St. Louis. It was somehow worse than I’d remembered. But that’s not what sticks in my craw. After all, you can’t have high expectations for a movie that lists the All State insurance spokesman as a co-star. No, what bothered me was a series of inexplicably horrible but ultimately successful decisions made by interim Tribe skipper Jake Taylor. You may recall that Taylor took the reins from Lou Brown following Brown’s heart attack mid-season. What did Taylor do wrong?

Stupid like a fox

1. He had no control of his team, Part 1
At one point, a war of words between CF Willie Hayes and RHP Rick Vaughn escalated into a fight between the two during a crushing loss to the Red Sox in the first game of a doubleheader. By itself, this isn’t so bad. But it quickly devolved into a team-wide brawl involving Taylor. Even the Don Baylors of the world, MLB’s worst managers, don’t have this happen to them.

2. He had no control of his team, Part 2
In the very next game, RF Pedro Cerrano (the future insurance spokesman) walks up to Taylor, in the 9th inning of a tie game, and tells him that he wants to pinch hit. Without even batting an eyelash, Taylor sends him in. Cerrano had clearly been in a season long slump. There was no reason at all to expect a successful outcome there. But more importantly, it wasn’t Cerrano’s decision to make. The fact that he hit a walk-off pinch hit homerun is moot.

3. He had no control of his team, Part 3
Going back to that fight for a second, what were the repercussions for Hayes? Apparently nothing because he pinch-ran as a prelude to Cerrano’s game-winner. All was forgiven. This isn’t ‘Nam, Jake Taylor. There are rules here.

4. He turned Isuro Tanaka into the everyday LF
Tanaka was a fine defensive outfielder. He had great range, a good arm, and was a max effort player. But he clearly lacked the power to be an everyday LF. It’s a power position. You simply must get extra base pop out of certain key positions. LF is chief among them.

5. He consistently set up Rick Vaughn to fail
Removing Vaughn from the rotation was a shrewd move, one that was probably unpopular with all the fans except for Randy Quaid. But Taylor wiped away any gain from that move by running Vaughn out to pitch in high-leverage situations, further damaging Vaughn’s fragile psyche. When pitchers are missing 10 mph off of their queso, you don’t use them down the stretch with games on the line.

6. Walking Beck to pitch to Parkman
I don’t care how much mojo you think Vaughn recovered by shaving a bolt into the back of his head or putting on a leather vest. He’d been throwing pus all year and the Tribe’s first World Series trip since 1954 was on the line. Parkman was a beast. It should’ve gone down with leaving Pedro in after 100 pitches in the ’03 ALCS as one of the dumbest moves in the annals of Major League history.

And yet, it worked, just like all of those things. In summation, Jake Taylor, you are no Lou Brown.


Filed under Humor, Movies

6 responses to “The Inexplicable Success of Manager Jake Taylor in Major League II

  1. heyzeus

    The follow up post: How many analogous decisions has Tony made in the past few seasons?

    I’ll start with the obvious: We had our own Tanaka, and he was so very Taguchi.

  2. Carlos Spicy Wiener

    To complete the analogy, Anthony Reyes was the phenom with the missing fastball; the wily veteran game 7 starter was already eerily named Schoup (Suppan); and there was even a veteran 3B quarreling with the manager about playing time. Major League II is the true story of the 2006 St. Louis Cardinals.

  3. Excellent points, especially reason #5. If I remember right, Vaughn was the starter for game 4 (the would-be clincher) or his team’s playoff series against the White Sox, and was left in to face Parkman with 2 on and a 2 run lead, and served up a walk-off homer to let Chicago back in the series. Now, maybe Cleveland didn’t have a reliable closer, but Taylor still should’ve gotten Vaughn out of there in that situation.

  4. Tanaka’s high VORP and excellent win share ratio make him a good candidate for starting in left field. He’s a prototypical 2 hitter with a remarkable OBP. He’d be a great CF, but you have Hayes already and you need his speed. You just need to generate more power from another position where power isn’t normally expected. Maybe they could sign Rod Barajas to play catcher.

    • This is true. I’ve no doubt neglected Tanaka’s incredible UZR and +/- scores. His glove may make up for the lack of pop out of LF. Sort of a Japanese Carl Crawford.

  5. Pingback: Pitchers and Catchers Report (to My List of Best Movie Pitchers and Catchers) |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s